SoutheastCon 2001 -- Software Competition
Comments

NOTE:  The primary objectives of this listing are to provide the teams with feed-back and a sense of their relative performance.  The teams were evaluated on the basis of the progress made towards a correct implementation.

1st:  University of Alabama-Birmingham
Good
Bad
- logic completely correct - TSS computed incorrectly and too often
- training by epoch - can not handle variable number of layers
- better understanding of bias  - less elegant use of MPI primatives
- less hardcoding, more robust

2nd:  Georgia Institute of Technology
Good
Bad
- great documentation - training by pattern
- good use of BCAST - infinite while-loop with no break
- good flow control and structure

3rd:  University of Kentucky
Good
Bad
- great use of BCAST / Reduction sums - training by pattern
- very elegant solution - incorrect use of unit biases
- overwriting weight array with delta wij's
- inner loop conceptually incorrect

4th:  University of South Carolina
Good
Bad
- good use of structs - no dynamic memory allocation, unused statically declared memory
- attempted modular code - weights randomly initialized in slaves, not master
- main iterative code not in main iterative event loop

5th:  Christian Brothers University
Good
Bad
- great dynamic memory allocation - each iteration sending of params, not needed
- weights sent too frequently and incorrectly
- training by pattern
- never applies the delta wij's
- no implementation of feed-forward or back-propagation code

6th:  University of West Florida
Good
Bad
- good explicit handshaking - no implementation of feed-forward or back-propagation code
- very little code implemented 
- training by pattern

7th:  Western Kentucky University
Good
Bad
- interesting initial weight distribution - no use of MPI for communication
- very little progress made

8th:  North Carolina A&T
Good
Bad
- used competition as a learning experience - very little progress made

9th:  University of North Florida
Good
Bad
- attended the session on Friday night - did not return on Saturday